All Season Ticket Packages include discounts for season ticket holders and their guests and can be used for any performance time within your package guidelines. Season Tickets and Season Ticket Guest discounts are not valid on New Year’s Eve.  Season Tickets must be ordered through our Box Office at 920-563-9505. Orders placed by November 30, 2023 qualify for Gold Pin Membership which entitles you to save 10% on most Fireside Gift Shop purchased throughout the year and special offers at select Fort Atkinson hotels and other retailers.

Premier Packages may be used during the first three performance weeks of each show.
Flex Packages may be used for any performance throughout the run of each show.

Season Ticket Packages Base Price With Tax & Facility Fee Savings Per Person
7 Show Premier $440.65 $509.19 $177.24
7 Show Flex Pack $461.65 $531.37 $155.05
6 Show Premier $395.70 $455.46 $132.90
6 Show Flex Pack $413.70 $474.42 $113.94
5 Show Premier $344.75 $395.35 $94.95
5 Show Flex Pack $354.75 $405.90 $84.40
4 Show Premier $283.80 $324.72 $67.52
4 Show Flex Pack $295.80 $337.40 $54.84
3 Show Premier $224.85 $256.20 $37.98
3 Show Flex Pack $233.85 $265.71 $28.47
2 Show Premier* $157.90 $179.24 $16.88
Season Packages Price** Savings Per Person
7 Show Premier $509.18 $177.24
7 Show Flex $531.37 $155.05
6 Show Premier $455.46 $132.90
6 Show Flex $474.42 $113.94
5 Show Premier $395.35 $94.95
5 Show Flex $405.90 $84.40
4 Show Premier $324.72 $67.52
4 Show Flex $337.40 $54.84
3 Show Premier $256.20 $37.98
3 Show Flex $265.71 $28.47
2 Show Premier $179.24 $16.88

* Both shows must be purchased at the same time to receive the Season Ticket price.

** Price includes Tax & Facility Fee

Dinner Theatre Packages do not include sales tax, soda, bar drinks, or gratuity. Tickets are subject to 5.5% sales tax and a $6.00 facility charge per ticket. Tickets are not refundable.  There will be a $35.00 fee assessed for all returned checks. Dining is required for all performances. Except for our Sunday Brunch and Thursday Evening Buffet you will be asked to select your entree choices when making reservations. All shows, dates, times, prices, and menus are subject to change.


Jersey Boys

January 4 – February 25, 2024
With phenomenal music, memorable characters, and great storytelling, JERSEY BOYS follows the fascinating evolution of four blue-collar kids who became one of the greatest successes in pop-music history. Winner of the Tony Award for Best Musical, JERSEY BOYS takes you behind the music of Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons to discover the secret of a 40-year friendship as the foursome work their way from the streets of New Jersey to the heights of stardom. Enjoy electrifying performances of chart-topping hits including “Sherry,” “Big Girls Don’t Cry,” and “My Eyes Adored You,” which took The Four Seasons to the Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall of Fame. (Contains explicit adult language. Not recommended for children.) Entree Choices: Pork Ribeye, Poached Salmon, Creole Chicken.

Fiddler on the Roof

February 29 – April 14, 2024
“A fiddler on the roof, sounds crazy, no?” Yet millions of people every year fall in love with Tevye, the long-suffering dairyman who struggles to find a balance between his traditions and his family. Now celebrating 60 years, as is The Fireside, we are proud to present a brand new revival of one of the most popular shows in our history. The show’s universal theme touches everyone, leaving audiences crying tears of both joy and sadness. Including such iconic songs as “Sunrise, Sunset,” “If I Were a Rich Man” and “Matchmaker, Matchmaker,” FIDDLER ON THE ROOF is the perfect mix of audience-pleasing humor and heart. Entree Choices: Beef Tenderloin, Chicken Cordon Bleu, Almond Cod.

Beautiful – The Carole King Musical

April 18 – May 26, 2024
Before she was hit-maker Carole King — she was Carole Klein, a spunky, young songwriter from Brooklyn with a unique voice. From the chart-topping hits she wrote for the biggest acts in music to her own life-changing, trailblazing success with Tapestry, BEAUTIFUL: The Carole King Musical takes you back to where it all began. Featuring such unforgettable classics as “You’ve Got a Friend,” “One Fine Day,” “Take Good Care of My Baby,” “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling,” and “Natural Woman,” this Tony® and Grammy® Award-winning musical phenomenon is filled with the songs you remember and a story you’ll never forget. Entree Choices: Rainbow Trout, Hanger Steak, Supreme Cut Chicken.


May 30 – July 14, 2024
Join us for a madcap revue with a hysterical, anything-goes, good natured sense of fun. The Little Sisters of Hoboken are in dire financial straits. It seems they must raise enough money to bury the last four of 52 dearly departed nuns who were accidentally poisoned by the convent cook, Sister Julia (Child of God). The five remaining sisters perform with quick paced, comic flair and high-spirited singing. It’s an outrageous premise for a long-running hit show that’s “sinfully” hilarious and definitely habit forming! Entree Choices: Shrimp Tempura, Braised Pork Belly, Chicken Piccata.

Matilda – The Musical

July 18 – September 1, 2024
Inspired by the genius of Roald Dahl, the Tony Award-winning Roald Dahl’s MATILDA The Musical is a captivating masterpiece packed with high-energy dance numbers and catchy songs. MATILDA tells the story of an extraordinary girl who, armed with a sharp mind, a vivid imagination, and psychokinetic powers dares to take a stand to change her story with miraculous results. Unloved by her cruel parents and evil headmistress, she impresses her teacher with courage and cleverness in a joyous celebration of one girl’s triumph over what’s “not right!” Entree Choices: Chicken Alfredo, Roast Pork Loin, Grilled Salmon.

Rocky – The Musical

September 12 – October 20, 2024
Entering the ring is a hard-hitting yet tender musical adaptation! Rocky Balboa is a small-time Philadelphia boxer who is chosen to take on the reigning world heavyweight champion, Apollo Creed, when the undefeated fighter’s scheduled opponent is injured. As he diligently trains for the fight, Rocky begins a relationship with Adrian, a wallflower who is tired of being pushed around by her brother. As their love grows, Rocky and Adrian each find their inner strength and bring out the best in each other. With equal parts grit and heart, Rocky is about the triumph of spirit, strength, and love. Entree Choices: Grilled Shrimp, Beef Short Rib, Stuffed Supreme Chicken.

Miracle on 34th Street

October 31 – December 22, 2024
Based on the beloved Christmas movie, MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET is a big brassy Broadway musical with a heart. Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade needs a new Santa. Enter Kris Kringle – a sweet and jolly old man who claims that he is the real Santa Claus. Thus begins this funny, warm, tuneful, and inspirational musical as Kris has to prove his claim in court and teach his cynical neighbor and her daughter to believe in the goodness and love that is Christmas. Written by Meredith Willson, the creator of THE MUSIC MAN, this is an unforgettable musical version of a classic Christmas tale. Premier dates 10/31 – 11/17. Entree Choices: Chicken and Ribs, Seared Duck, Steak Diane.